Useful tool. Wrong job
A Zestimate is good at one thing: giving you a rough sense of where your home sits, in about ten seconds, for free. It is not built to set a listing price, and Zillow does not claim it is. Zillow itself says the Zestimate is not an appraisal. That is not a knock on the tool. It is the tool telling you what it is for.
The error rate is printed right there
Zillow publishes how accurate its estimate is, and the figures were refreshed on September 30, 2026. Nationally, the median error is 1.77% for homes currently listed for sale and 7.20% for off-market homes. If your home is not on the market, you are in the second group — the looser one.
Put dollars on it. On a $600,000 Michigan home, 7.2% is about $43,200. On a $900,000 home, it is about $65,000. Either direction. Price off the low side and you leave money on the table. Price off the high side and you sit, then cut, then explain the cuts to every buyer who asks what is wrong with the place.
Source: Zillow's published Zestimate accuracy figures, refreshed September 30, 2026. These are national figures.
What a model cannot walk through
The estimate is built from public records and nearby sales. That leaves real gaps:
- Work that was never reported. The finished lower level, the kitchen redone without a permit trail, the bath added years ago — if it is not in the records, it is not in the number.
- Condition, either way. A roof replaced last spring and a roof that is quietly at the end of its life can look identical in a database. They are not identical to a buyer.
- What makes your street different. Michigan is full of mixed markets — a lakefront home two doors from an inland one, an older estate next to a new build, a large lot in a town of small ones. A model averages. Buyers do not.
- Timing. The model works from sales that already closed. The market you will actually sell into is the one in front of you, not the one behind you.
So what is it for?
A starting point. Check it, note it, then set it aside and build the real number the old way: recent comparable sales that actually match your home, honest adjustments for condition and updates, and a read on the buyers who are active in your town right now. That is slower than ten seconds. It is also how a price holds up when a real buyer, a real appraiser, and a real negotiation test it.
If you want a first look, the home-value page below is free and takes a minute. If you want the number you would actually list at, that is a conversation — with comps on the table, not an algorithm behind a curtain.
Want a number you can trust?
An algorithm has never walked your house. Tell me about the place. You get a real read from a local agent — what it would likely bring, and what your options are if you decide to sell.
Got it. You will hear back shortly — usually the same day.
Eric Galpin is part of The Blake Team — $139 million in team sales — with Epique Realty, and holds a 5.0-star rating from 21 Google reviews.
Start the conversation
Eric Galpin | The Blake Team | Epique Realty

